Showing posts with label science of everyday experiences. Show all posts
Showing posts with label science of everyday experiences. Show all posts

Monday, February 22, 2010

“Lie to Me”, Temporary Autism and Malcolm Gladwell’s Igon Values

I just finished with Malcolm Gladwell’s Blink: The Power of Thinking Without Thinking. It raises some interesting points, and is certainly an entertaining enough read, but I have to say it’s got my logic gland a little bit inflamed.

logic_glandLocation of the logic gland

Blink deals with the processes that take place in our minds before we’re aware we’ve thought about them (i.e. first impressions). He discusses job interviews, market research, and police (over)reactions, among other things. I’d like to report the take-away message of it all, but to be honest I’m kind of confused what it was supposed to be.

Half the time Gladwell is describes how our first impressions are more correct than we give them credit for, and half the time that they’re terribly, terribly wrong. That’s fine, but without outlining where the distinction lies, it doesn’t help anyone better understand how they might change their thinking on first impressions. The only point that is put forward is that snap judgements are correct if you’re an expert and trained to make objective evaluations, and wrong if you’re a non-expert. Which does all of us non-experts a lot of good.

As an example, Gladwell explains how meticulous analysis of facial expressions, down to specific muscle movements, can carry crucial clues to the person’s intentions. This comes from research by Paul Ekman (Tim Roth on Lie to Me) and the meticulous system he developed, which involves recording facial expressions and breaking down expressions frame-by-frame, giving each one particular, inaccessible codenames.

Those are Action Units 89 and 104 right there, and they tell me Tim Roth had the veal parmigiana for dinner last night

Following this praise for scrutinizing small details to pick out the truth is a complete rebuttal of this methodology. Gladwell goes through how over-analysis of data cost “Blue Team” in the American Army’s Millennium Challenge 2002 war-game. They chose to carefully scrutinize their data, give everything inaccessible acronyms, and break everything down into categories. And this time, that was a bad thing.

My problem with Gladwell’s writing is the same as that recently voiced by Steven Pinker, in response to Gladwell’s most recent book, What the Dog Saw – And Other Adventures. He calls it Gladwell’s Igon value problem, after a particularly damning error (Eigen value, a term any mathematician knows, was the term Gladwell meant to use). Talking about What the Dog Saw, Pinker writes:

The problem with Gladwell’s generalizations about prediction is that he never zeroes in on the essence of a statistical problem and instead overinterprets some of its trappings. For example, in many cases of uncertainty, a decision maker has to act on an observation that may be either a signal from a target or noise from a distractor (a blip on a screen may be a missile or static; a blob on an X-ray may be a tumor or a harmless thickening). Improving the ability of your detection technology to discriminate signals from noise is always a good thing, because it lowers the chance you’ll mistake a target for a distractor or vice versa. But given the technology you have, there is an optimal threshold for a decision, which depends on the relative costs of missing a target and issuing a false alarm. By failing to identify this trade-off, Gladwell bamboozles his readers with pseudoparadoxes about the limitations of pictures and the downside of precise information.

Steven_PinkerWhack! Pinker-slapped!

Gladwell doesn’t get statistics. This prompted Pinker’s response for What the Dog Saw, and was the case in his earlier writings as well. While one scientist’s views, a remarkable event, or a business success story may make for interesting discussion points, it is never the be all and end all. For every example of failed market research, how many times has it been successful? For every time experts identify a forgery, how often are they fooled? A single story makes for a good anecdote, but it is not convincing that it is representative of a phenomenon. The stories he writes on are, after all, remarkable in some way, or else they wouldn’t be worth publishing.

Perhaps most frustrating was his coining of the term “temporary autism” to refer to the lack of comprehension we have of fine details in the first rapid moments of experiencing a novel situation, person, or object. I’ll try to ignore how offensive this is to those afflicted with autism and their loved ones, but seriously, I don’t complain of momentary paraplegia whenever my leg falls asleep. That’s not cool.

Malcolm_GladwellBad, Gladwell, bad!

“Temporary autism” is supposed to represent that we cannot comprehend every detail of a situation and make judgements based on only our (often misled) first impressions. He describes how we need to avoid falling into that trap where the rest of our cognitive processes supposedly shut down. I think he takes this completely the wrong way. People don’t fall into a pathological state (which, if true could be extremely legally problematic) whenever they don’t have enough information. Instead, they operate based on whatever information they have, and then once a complete picture is available, full reasoning and such can kick in. To call everyone potentially irrational and unemotional is pretty damn misanthropic.

Okay, that’s enough for now. I still plan on reading Outliers and What the Dog Saw, but needed to vent about Blink for now. If I have to say one thing, it’s take your Gladwell with a grain of salt.

p.s. If you’ve read Gladwell before (and maybe even if you haven’t), you should read this essay: I Dream in Malcolm Gladwell. Its funny, and helped ease some of my frustrations about this book.

Oh, and here’s Steven Pinker’s Review:

New York Times: Malcolm Gladwell, Eclectic Detective

Monday, January 25, 2010

The 5 Second Rule - Expanded

For every rule, there are exceptions. Even something like the 5 second rule, which has saved many a spilled college student's dinner. Check it out:

10second_rule_flowchartSource:Audrey Fukman and Andy Wright

I like to advocate a realistic approach to bacteria in the world around us; while it’s probably not the best idea to eat a pound of soil (for several reasons), contact with non-pristine surfaces doesn’t necessarily make food irreversibly spoiled. In fact, researchers have shown that food may be okay after being left as long as 30 seconds on a cafeteria floor.

There’s lots of places you wouldn’t want to eat food off the ground (hospitals, barnyards, and daycares come to mind) but its possible that we’ve become so accustomed to clean environments, and grown so afraid of all bacteria that we’ve lost perspective on the world around us. Not that long ago the closest thing to a table available was a tree stump or rock. And no one wiped those down with Lysol first.

Monday, November 30, 2009

Vitamin Water is a Stupid Product

Alas. It’s been a long time since work has kept me up till 3am. But I have something to share - I loved this Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal comic:

SMBC20091129

Thursday, November 19, 2009

A thousand taxonomists cried out into the night…

Whoever said cladistics were useless?

Certainly I haven’t.*

An example has just surfaced that shows the importance of taxonomy to this day. Sadly, taxonomists’ vindication may come at the cost of a species of fish, the flapper skate, now recognized as critically-endangered. Classification of this fish as the same species as the related blue skate has allowed the flapper to be fished almost to extinction, and all because of a classification error.

skatePictured: The Flapper Skate. So cute!

So while the fact remains that taxonomy is mostly an outdated field, there might still be some role for the science of natural classification yet. Just not in any of the important sciences.

Wired Science: ID Error Leaves Fish at Edge of Extinction

*This may be a lie.

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Coffee contains – gasp! – CHEMICALS!!!!!!

Ever wonder just what is in a cup of coffee? At first, you might not want to.

coffeePhoto source: Simone♠13

On the short list, in addition to caffeine, your average brew also contains:

  • Dimethyl disulfide, which contributes to the odour of human waste
  • 2-Ethylphenol, a cockroach pheromone
  • Putrescine, a toxic breakdown product of rancid meat 

While I don’t believe the article writer set out to have this effect, a couple comments indicate he has in fact scared some readers. Of course, it all depends on how you want to take it. Some might be made uneasy at the mention of strange-sounding chemicals with scary qualifiers, and opt to eschew their coffee tomorrow morning. I, however am not about to abandon my sweet, caffeinated nectar of the gods morning cup just yet.

Coffee’s been around for a while now, and (debates about small effects on overall health aside) it’s safe to say that the compounds in coffee, especially at cup-a-day levels, are harmless. This presentation of facts is a good illustration that one shouldn’t be scared of something just because it has chemical names attached to it. The unknown is scary and chemicals particularly intimidating, but any everyday material could be made to sound scarier if placed in the right light.

That cup your coffee’s in? Aluminum and silicon oxides
The table it’s sitting on? Reducing sugar polymers and lignins
The spoon you mixed with? Smelted iron-carbon alloy

You don’t even want to know what sort of nasty phytochemicals are in that banana you were about to eat.

The point being, just because you can name something chemically (and even describe potentially unsavoury places it might be found in nature or industry), that doesn’t make it bad for you. When someone says that a product contains (cue spooky music) chemicals, that person is trying to scare you, usually to buy their product. Case in point:

Note that they never say those chemicals are not present in their product (they are), just that they are present in the competitors. Sneaky bastards.

Anyways, that said, I’m thirsty. I’m off to grab a nice cold glass of dihydrogen monoxide.

Source:
Wired Science: What’s Inside a Cup of Coffee?

Friday, October 2, 2009

Ig Nobels Awarded

Forget those other awards coming out next week, the Ig Nobel awards were awarded last night.

ignobel
For the uninitiated, the Ig Nobels are awards that celebrate research that “makes you laugh, then makes you think”. They’re doing a great job of promoting interesting science, I always enjoy seeing who wins.

Winners this year:

  • VETERINARY MEDICINE PRIZE: Catherine Douglas and Peter Rowlinson of Newcastle University, Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, UK, for showing that cows who have names give more milk than cows that are nameless.
  • PEACE PRIZE: Stephan Bolliger, Steffen Ross, Lars Oesterhelweg, Michael Thali and Beat Kneubuehl of the University of Bern, Switzerland, for determining — by experiment — whether it is better to be smashed over the head with a full bottle of beer or with an empty bottle.
  • ECONOMICS PRIZE: The directors, executives, and auditors of four Icelandic banks — Kaupthing Bank, Landsbanki, Glitnir Bank, and Central Bank of Iceland — for demonstrating that tiny banks can be rapidly transformed into huge banks, and vice versa — and for demonstrating that similar things can be done to an entire national economy.
  • CHEMISTRY PRIZE: Javier Morales, Miguel Apátiga, and Victor M. Castaño of Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, for creating diamonds from liquid — specifically from tequila.
  • MEDICINE PRIZE: Donald L. Unger, of Thousand Oaks, California, USA, for investigating a possible cause of arthritis of the fingers, by diligently cracking the knuckles of his left hand — but never cracking the knuckles of his right hand — every day for more than sixty (60) years.
  • PHYSICS PRIZE: Katherine K. Whitcome of the University of Cincinnati, USA, Daniel E. Lieberman of Harvard University, USA, and Liza J. Shapiro of the University of Texas, USA, for analytically determining why pregnant women don't tip over.
  • LITERATURE PRIZE: Ireland's police service (An Garda Siochana), for writing and presenting more than fifty traffic tickets to the most frequent driving offender in the country — Prawo Jazdy — whose name in Polish means "Driving License".
  • PUBLIC HEALTH PRIZE: Elena N. Bodnar, Raphael C. Lee, and Sandra Marijan of Chicago, Illinois, USA, for inventing a brassiere that, in an emergency, can be quickly converted into a pair of gas masks, one for the brassiere wearer and one to be given to some needy bystander.
  • MATHEMATICS PRIZE: Gideon Gono, governor of Zimbabwe’s Reserve Bank, for giving people a simple, everyday way to cope with a wide range of numbers — from very small to very big — by having his bank print bank notes with denominations ranging from one cent ($.01) to one hundred trillion dollars ($100,000,000,000,000).
  • BIOLOGY PRIZE: Fumiaki Taguchi, Song Guofu, and Zhang Guanglei of Kitasato University Graduate School of Medical Sciences in Sagamihara, Japan, for demonstrating that kitchen refuse can be reduced more than 90% in mass by using bacteria extracted from the feces of giant pandas.

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

The Wikipedia Model Does Not Apply For Medicine

Having some limited background in the biomedical sciences (though I consider myself first a chemist), I’ve grown tired of folk remedies that I can understand have little to no plausibility. Sometimes I’ll humour the person who suggests a course of action to me, but for the most point I will ignore anecdotal recommendations in favour of real medicine. It often frustrates me to see people who believe themselves (or sell their image as) more educated on health than medical professionals.

That’s why, when I read the article, Ask Strangers for Medical Advice, coming from a pop science outlet (Wired), I just about shat a brick. The article plugs a site called CureTogether, which allows hypochondriacs everywhere to track their progress on combating whatever ails them.

If all participants were honest, diligent, and meticulous, with some way of verifying the information reported, then the idea of CureTogether could work. The problem is, there is no way to track if what people report as results is actually what is going on. Most people are not meticulous. Many are not diligent. And there’s probably enough dishonest people out there to make this site’s information next to useless.

Even the image provided by Wired highlights the failings of this method:

acnestats

The chart tracks various methods used to combat acne. The credulous eye sees that “Dr. Hauschka Natural Skin Care” seems to do the best job, but ignores the fact that this value is based on only two respondents. Without the source data I can’t be sure, but the data for this point could probably fall pretty much anywhere by chance (i.e. this likely isn’t a significant result). That doesn’t stop the fact that most people will now take away the message that this is the “best” treatment. And the remedy gets free publicity from the Wired article, as well, which it does not deserve based on this data.

The author writes:

Even if some bad apples make their way into the community, it may still be a better source of information than some peer-reviewed literature, since top scientists have been caught fabricating data about medications and Elsevier has published entire fake journals dedicated to bolstering the reputation of Merck drugs.

Which I find offensive. Yes, drug companies can be bastards. But that doesn’t mean that their information is useless. The peer-review process is in place to reduce this kind of dishonesty, and it does, by replicating and revising information when new results come to light.

Wired reports this issue as science failing the common person, and so they appeal to the experience of the crowd. The problem is that one person’s opinion does not constitute proof, and combining many opinions only amplifies any errors in judgement. The plural of anecdote is not evidence. Shame on you, Wired Science.

Wired Science: Ask Strangers for Medical Advice

Thursday, August 6, 2009

Math nerds count cards…..

Chemistry geeks count M&Ms. County fairs may need to start employing Vegas thugs just to keep the chemists from exploiting the game.

And here I thought my second year chemical structure class had no real-world applications…….

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

The Good Old Days of Drug Marketing

Just what the doctor ordered.

cocainedrops

For an enlightening look into the past of pharmaceutical marketing, check out this article to see lots more vintage ads:

Weed, Booze, Cocaine, and Other Old School “Medicine” Ads

While some inevitably take this as a condemnation of the pharmaceutical industry, I see it as a testament to the naïveté of the past and indeed how far we have come in our understanding of medicine.

What gaffes might we see on such a compilation in another hundred years?

Source: http://www.pharmacytechs.net/blog/old-school-medicine-ads

Friday, July 17, 2009

The Illusion of Sex: Contrast and Gender Perception

illusionofsex
Image courtesy Dr. Richard Russell, Harvard University

Interesting research in press for the journal Perception shows that a contributing factor to perceived gender of a face is merely contrast. The above image is of the same androgynous face, digitally treated to both increase (left) and decrease (right) the contrast, and the result is a change in perceived gender. Without any anatomical differences, the relative darkness of lips and eyes compared to skin change our perception, and changes our fundamental idea of what we are seeing.

This image took third prize at the visual illusion of the year contest, though the phenomenon is more than just a trick of visual perception. Recognition of things like faces (and voices) is a far more complicated process than it seems from everyday experience. Computers have a hard time with them because we use numerous shortcuts (heuristics) in our processing, which often aren’t logical to a machine (or we don’t know them yet). This image illustrates well how we take visual cues and build heuristics from the world around us, and how these shortcuts can lead us to make gross changes in perception from small changes in input. Usually this works well – imagine finding a friend in a crowded room if you had to concentrate on the face of every single person?

There is a cautionary note here. This work highlights the fallibility of our senses, and that we need to be careful to stay objective in cases where we can be fooled by what we see or hear (taste, touch, or smell?). This is especially true in cases, like advertising,  where editors may use information like this to skew our understanding or opinions. Stay vigilant. Stay skeptical. Stay classy.

Monday, April 28, 2008

You don't really exist

So I just finished reading Steve Grand's book, Creation, which was a really interesting exercise in looking at the world through a different lens. Although he aims the book toward the construction of artificial life, the insights he has are pretty cool as to what is actually real and what is not (here's a hint: everything is real, and nothing is real). The book was definitely a score from the discount shelf in Chapters. *self-congratulatory pat on the back*

An interesting point he brings up (pretty sure it wasn't his original statement, but I have no idea who its from) is that within the span of several (seven?) years, you as a person will have completely exchanged atoms with your environment. As such, we are all merely organization of atoms in space, that in turn direct the movement of other atoms, and eventually recycled to the external environment.

Within a certain amount of time, all of the original scaffold is gone and you are now made up of all the new atoms you have inhaled, eaten, and absorbed. Grand states that we are thus made more of energy than matter. Think about it. Think harder. It's sorta crazy, eh? Remember that wild party ten years back you remember having a blast at - well turns out you weren't actually there. The you that sits reading this now, anyway. Cue eerie twilight zone music.

Now of course, the you that was there in the past is the same organization of matter, and so there's little chance of a case holding up in court of a criminal stating he wasn't at the scene of a crime because the collection of cells and molecules that robbed the bank don't exist anymore. It does give reason for pause, however, and should maybe change our view of how we interact with our environment, as we're constantly in flux with it, and not separate from it.

Next week: How as much as you may think you ate bacon and eggs for breakfast this morning, you actually just had toast.